Log in | Register
Forum > General / Nonfiction > Thread

Ms.O 2025 predictions: Natalia Kovaleva vs Andrea Shaw

Mar 26, 2025 - edited Mar 26, 2025 - permalink

In recent video IFBB/Olympia judge Terrick El Guindy make a statement:

"If Natalia has a back and Natalia is conditioned she can be a threat to dethrone Andrea Shaw for years to come"

Sourse https://youtu.be/jjY9dN7Tu6Y?si=pQo7TF4Kpp5mw...

Terrick El Guindy`s direct speech:

"Natalia Kovaleva is bigger than Andrea Shaw. She has the size. She has small waist. We have seen Andrea Shaw beat a lot of competitors you know we saw her lose to Angela Yeo because she wasnt at her best but I think Natalia brings different perspective. If Natalia has a back and Natalia is conditioned shes not a threat to win one show from Andrea Shaw she can be a threat to dethrone Andrea Shaw for years to come, thats the potential. She is like the Andrew Jake of women`s bodybuilding. She has all the tools to became Ms. Olympia. She need to get the back and the conditioning. If she does that she could be next one in line to be Ms. Olympia"

What do you guys think on this topic after Terrick El Guindy`s words ?

Mar 26, 2025 - permalink

I think it’ll depend on the federation's decision if they want to push for a bigger look. Natalia is bigger than Andrea, but even in the bodybuilding class, they still tend to not go for a look as muscular as Natalia. She has even complained about it in her instagram that in previous shows judges have told her she was “too big”.

They both have symmetry, so I hope she is able to achieve a good conditioning so the deciding factor will be size.I hope they do push for size as I’m starting to see very little difference between physique and bodybuilding, so going for a more muscular look like Natalia will differentiate both categories even more.

Mar 26, 2025 - permalink

I hope they do push for size as I’m starting to see very little difference between physique and bodybuilding, so going for a more muscular look like Natalia will differentiate both categories even more.

I totally agree, and that can be said for all the women’s division. Bikini, which I never cared for, now has some solid muscular competitors looking like figure girls, and you have figure girls and wellness competitors looking like they could do well competing in the physique division.

The lines are blurring.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

I hope Anastasia Leonova qualifies for the Olympia. I would love to see her on stage. For women’s physique, I would love to see Rosario Willumsen.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Not sure who will win but…

Recently saw Natalia bench 315 for ten reps in a YouTube shorts clip with ease. If raw strength were a factor in the judging, would be hard not to pick her this year

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Natalia is for sure more stronger of Andrea, there is a YouTube video of last year that show it. Angela Yeo is in the same video too. Angela is on the middle as strength.

cgsweat
Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Unfortunately strength does not factor at all into who will win the Olympia.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Wasn’t Anastasia Leonova kept out of the Olympia because Russians couldn’t get a passport or something? Where’s Natalia located?

Mar 28, 2025 - edited Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Here's the thought that gets me. Andrea Shaw was bigger at the 2021 Ms. Olympia and was given the unnecessary advice to downsize. You know the old conundrum of these female BBs getting too big even though it's called bodybuilding. So I assume she's at a place that makes TPTB happy. So as long as Andrea's conditioning stays on point why would they allow someone who's bigger than her come in take the crown? Doesn't make much sense to me.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Where’s Natalia located?

Phoenix, Arizona. Natalia has been living in the US since 2019

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

I think I probably said this before, but Natalia’s breast implants look ridiculous when she’s shredded for a show and I feel like that takes away from her overall appearance in the eyes of the judges. Don’t get me wrong, I still think she’s very attractive, but in terms of the sport, I think it’s the wrong decision to give her the highest title.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Andrea has that classier look that the federation seems to want. Nat looks like a bulked up porn star.

Mar 28, 2025 - permalink

Andrea Shaw

Mar 30, 2025 - permalink

Wasn’t Anastasia Leonova kept out of the Olympia because Russians couldn’t get a passport or something? Where’s Natalia located?

Yes, but now that she and Hafiz are officially married she has an Israeli passport and can come to the US.

Mar 30, 2025 - permalink

Yes, but now that she and Hafiz are officially married she has an Israeli passport and can come to the US.

Natalia is located in Arizona, she lives in the US

Mar 30, 2025 - permalink

I really hope Natalia shows some crazy conditioning and wins the Olympia. She's so beautiful and massive. If she hadn't had those implants and lips corrections, she would be even better.

Mar 30, 2025 - permalink

I really hope Natalia shows some crazy conditioning and wins the Olympia. She's so beautiful and massive. If she hadn't had those implants and lips corrections, she would be even better.

Agreed

« first < prev Page 1 of 1 next > last »