Improving the image comments

I believe THIS is the discussion. This is a page with the sole purpose of objectifying women. In this case muscular women.

Even if that is what most use it for, it doesn't need to be shouted into the ether at the top of our lungs. It could be a page celebrating these women's achievements.

So I guess “boing” makes some of us sick because we believe we are not a part of making the women into objects. We want to feel that we are here for a higher purpose. I’m afraid we are not, but that’s totally ok.

It makes us sick, because it is distasteful, even if you see a hot woman on the street you don't go up to her and say boing. That doesn't mean you can't find her attractive, but no need to be crude just because you are anonymous on the internet. Somehow that doesn't compel me to loose my morals.

I personally believe that we can be good and decent people while drooling over these pictures/clips. It’s not a question of right and wrong. At least if you do come here. Then maybe you should not.

You can drool over images without announcing it to the world is what I'm saying. When I was 10 I drooled over the lingiere section of mail order catalogues, but I didn't want to send letters to the company / models announcing it.

I also think that the majority of the comments holds no content. I choose not to be bothered. The pics usually steal my attention.

Being a lurker is fine too, more people should exercise that right. If they have nothing of value to add best hold their thoughts.

Keeping up with all the images on this site is time consuming enough, so why should we have to take time to think up a decent comment every time we make one? There are only so many things you can say, and therefore repetition is inevitable. The only comments I would want to see eradicated are the derogatory or sexist/sexual ones, which can be crass beyond belief.

Dude, are you for real? You are complaining that keeping up with the images is hard work?

If you have nothing worthwhile to say nobody is forcing you to comment. This is not "that other site" that forces every user to post or else.

If I want to make a comment I will, if I don't I wont. It seems you are the one with nothing worthwhile to say. Nobody is gonna force me to do anything. You obviously can't understand English, and totally missed my point.

If I want to make a comment I will, if I don't I wont. It seems you are the one with nothing worthwhile to say. Nobody is gonna force me to do anything. You obviously can't understand English, and totally missed my point.

I don't know what was your point then? You were clearly complaining about "keeping up with all the images"

How about if you don't like comments, or they annoy you, don't read them. After all you do have to scroll down the page to get to them. We already have a way to report rude, and abusive comments and the moderaters seem to do a good job policing them without going overboard dictatorship. Lastly, it's sounds like a real good idea to only have comments be visible to members. Other than that, IMO, nothing needs fixing.<

I think the problem is that many of the comments are on the border. Because this is a site to which people go because they admire or love the look of buff women, many of the comments are bound to have sexual overtones. Further, many of the women whose pictures end up here are posting deliberately sexual pictures. Finally, there are a great many levels of muscularity displayed on this site, and they generate different types of responses. --- The most important thing is to remind users every so often that they should not post anything that they would not want the bodybuilder in the picture to read. Most of us, when reminded, will use judgement.

I have to say I try to keep my responses as clean and supportive as possible, but sometimes I err.

I don't know what was your point then? You were clearly complaining about "keeping up with all the images"

No I was not complaining about keeping up with the images, I like doing that. However it takes a long time. What I was complaining about was having to think up something appropriate to say everytime I want to make a comment. As long as a comment is not derogatory or sexual it should be allowed, however basic it may be.

As long as a comment is not derogatory or sexual it should be allowed, however basic it may be.

What was again the third problem category? Stupid and inane comments?

Further, many of the women whose pictures end up here are posting deliberately sexual pictures.

That's no excuse for bad comments.

This thread should be retitled “comment confessionals.”

It took me some time to understand why I suddenly needed to log in to see the comments. But now, after reading these two discussions I think I understand.

Etc., etc., etc., etc., ad infinitum.

Here's another kind of comment I never want to see - someone's blathering, pseudo-intellectual senior thesis. And you're lecturing other people about narcissism?

What about the imagery that boasts sexuality? I don't mean perceived but provocative imagery that is best found on a pay-per-view site? Those postings are obviously looking for a validating comment that falls short of newly established comment protocols.

A good comment would be something like a poetic compliment. It does happen, and I appreciate when someone's capable of articulating something I'm feeling. I also appreciate observant comments that compel me to look at the picture twice (this could be something in the background -- anything).

A comment like "sexy" does not add much, but whatever, it's understandable. Demanding poetry or insight every time is too much.

"Boing" is juvenile. This could conceivably be funny, but I agree that it's generally "trashy."

Up/down voting comments would be nice.

I don't know what it would take to implement something like this is there any way you could make a band comment list and if somebody were to type in that type of sleazy comment that they can get a warning or get banned for a certain amount of time is that a possibility I don't know if there's anything like that on here

Have we considered, rather than viewing the comments as low quality, perhaps our expectations are too high?

What is the function/intent of the comment field to begin with?

Like anything on the great Internet, the majority of the information put in by “the crowd” will be junk.

Why can’t we simply view this as a natural feature, rather than a problem to be conquered?

I think the comments do serve a purpose: they create a sense of participation and sometimes, regardless of perceived quality, a sense of discourse. In short, they create a method to be involved with the site. And that’s a good thing. Right?

Totally agree.... well thought out and expressed.

I think the exact opposite.

I love doing a search on comments 'wow' then 'wooooow' then 'wooooooow' then 'woooooooooooow' because if this is someone's instant reaction is usually means the photo is good. Other great search terms are 'sexy', 'baseball', 'peak', 'split'. Short comments are usually someone's most honest emotional reaction. Capturing that in comments is golden. I wouldn't like to see that limited for the sake of the illusion of making the site more intelligent.

It is not about making site more intelligent, it is slow down Spam comments and better rules about commenting behaviour , thousands of same words in small varations of same people in short time Short comments are still possible but not endless by same

Short comments are usually someone's most honest emotional reaction.

Good comments need more than honesty.

• I would not genocide them. I would not mow them down with a machine gun. I would not throw them down the stairs or out a 10th floor window. *

"I mean, it may have crossed my mind... but I've definitely decided these punishments would be just a bit over-the-top..."

Is waterboarding still on the table?

Is waterboarding still on the table?

I think the purpose of that is to extract information. That is something I definitely would not want to do.

I think the purpose of that is to extract information. That is something I definitely would not want to do.

Touché

Or they are reactions by persons who most eagerly want to be seen as someone who is into "sexy" girls.

Being honest about something that has questionable truth value is not really valuable.

I do not hate or despise these guys. I would not genocide them. I would not mow them down with a machine gun. I would not throw them down the stairs or out a 10th floor window. I just don't enjoy listening to them and I don't enjoy their company and I don't think they are intelligent or interesting.

I just can't imagine an intelligent or interesting person making comments like those. But I can imagine a person who thinks he is interesting and intelligent, against the perception of everyone around them, making those comments.

People who live according to their instant reactions are usually incontinent in other ways too.

I have had my own wows and whoas but I can't imagine why my mindless instant reaction would mean anything to anyone else. Unless this is some kind of psychotherapy with a goal of helping me to accept and embrace my wows and whoas. Except that I have lost my wows and whoas and now my instant reaction is to think that there's again another girl asking for attention by displaying her body. Except when she looks nice and seems to be doing real sports. In that case I just think it's a girl advertising her hobby. Say Ayane Takenaka.

The more irrational and self-absorbed the person is, the bigger the wows and whoas will be. You have two independent variables that produce what you see. That makes it almost worthless as data. Who will more probably say boing? The person who really sees something worth boinging about? Or the person who is in general more prone to announcing his bodily reactions? "I gotta poo now." Yeah, thanks for telling us.

I'm a lion! See me drool!

I'm straight up an intellectual. I prefer intelligent comments too. But I search using those short comments. Because I know they are a reliable indication of how people feel about an image. I think if you were a PHD in data management, you would try not to limit too much those kinds of comments. We live in a world where AI will soon be running all our searches and short comment data will be one of the parameters AI uses to sort content. I just think it's shooting yourself in the foot to limit it too much. Some like 'boing' is worthless because it is on every post, but something like 'great peak' is currently the only way to search for peaked biceps. It will help AI sort things. I'm saying, be careful what you limit so that you can future proof the site. Don't let your emotional needs for better comments get in the way of effective data management.

But I can imagine a person who thinks he is interesting and intelligent, against the perception of everyone around them, making those comments.

Does this include psychological analysis of total strangers from 12 years old to their maybe their 70s?