Seems like it would be useful, and avoid pop ups and extra clicks. Its annoying when you see how many favorites there are, and can see the star but its just for show evidently.. Some forward thinking 8)
I'm generally not in favor of adding stuff to the interface unnecessarily, but I kind of see what he means, the star icon is already there below each thumbnail, and out of the way enough that I don't think misclicks would be much of a problem. Maybe a double-click on it to add a favorite, for extra safety?
Actually, on a side note it would be useful if that star icon were colored in for pics we already have favorited or +1'd. I personally use +1's partly as a marker to know when I've downloaded a pic, it would be nice to be able to see that from the thumbnails.
I guess I could see making the star clickable, which would really only work if I also use it to show your favorited status for the pic. I guess +1's and favorites would look the same.
I am not a fan of double clicking in web UIs, it's very rarely done and not intuitive to users.
Its annoying when you see how many favorites there are, and can see the star but its just for show
evidently.. Some forward thinking 8)